Earlier this year, I wrote about the Morris Everett Auction Part I which was held through Profiles in History. Just to recap – Everett tried to collect at least one lobby card from every American film made and is now selling off the collection. Back in June, there were certainly some choice lots, but the prices didn’t quite gel for me so I held off. This past week came the highly anticipated (for me anyway) Part II which included some Ann Dvorak treasures my little heart desperately desired, so I threw my hat (ie credit card) in the ring. I even visited Profiles in History in person and looked through all the lots to see the cards that were not pictured in the catalog. Gloves were off and I was ready!
I will revealÂ upfront that I walked away with nothing. Absolutely nothing. Yeah, super disappointing. Still, there are some amazing Ann Dvorak pieces that are worth sharing and I will try my best to not let the bitter grapes show through. And now I present: all the lobby cards that are not in my collection! (The nice professional photos were pulled off of Invaluable. The lousy shots with thumbs visible are the photos I look at the auction house.)
My bid: $950
End price: $1,000 + premiums
Let’s start off with my true heartbreak of the auction, an original 1932 release Scarface lobby card. This is one of twoÂ Scarface cards to picture Ann.Â Â I have the other one, but had only seen this one once, 14 years ago. At that time, I think the dealer wanted $1,250 and sold it shortly thereafter. I had actually forgotten what it looked like and was over the moon to see it again. I bid $950 which would have ended up being around $1,250 with tax and premiums and is by far the most I would have ever paid for a piece of Ann paper. Alas, I was outbid by a mere $50 though I like to think that even if I had gone a little higher I would have still been outbid.
My bid: $450
End price: 1,000 + premiums
This is my other true heartbreak. In all my years of collecting, I had never seen any cards fromÂ Stranger in Town, so I was very excited to see 5 cards up for auction. Unfortunately,Â Â Ann is only on the two cards shown here, and they were included in a lot of Â 52 (that’s right, 52) First National/Warner Bros cards. Bidding $450 was really a stretch for me because lobby cards with Ann Dvorak, David Manners, and Chic Sale aren’t exactly sought after, but I figured if I won, I could recoup my losses by selling the others. Unfortunately, it was not to be.
My bid: $350
End price: $850 + premiums
Just because the opening bid was low (relatively speaking), I bid on this lot of 16 lobby cards from 3 Maurice Chevalier films which included 4 cards with Ann fromÂ The Way to Love. I already had 2 of the cards, but figured what hell. No dice.
My bid: $0
End price: $1,200 + premiums
Midnight AlibiÂ is another title I had never seen a lobby card from. Unfortunately, this was another one of those massive lots with 46 cards from multiple Warner Bros/First National films, with an opening bid of $600, so I didn’t even bother.
My bid: $0
End price: $950 + premiums
This is another honey of a card that I had never seen. Again, it was included in a large lot of 45 Warner Bros/First National cards. Considering I had paid around $20 for each of the twoÂ CroonerÂ cards I already own, I just couldn’t justify the $600 opening bid for this one card.
My bid: 0
End price: $1,100 + premiums
Yet another giant lot of 36 cards, this time featuring Native American portrayals. For whatever reason,Â Massacre cards pop up every now and then, and I own the other Ann card that was included in this lot, so I did not have a hard time passing on it.
By bid: $0
End price: $2,250 + premiums
This is the first time I have ever seen aÂ HousewifeÂ card, so I was really disappointed to see it included in a lot of 17 early Bette Davis cards. I never had a fighting chance.
My bid: $0
End bid: $3,000
This card fromÂ The Guardman is chopped off at the top and was included in a lot of 53 MGM cards, so there was no way I was going for it. Still, it’s fun to see that extra-girl Ann made it onto a card.
My bid: $0
End price: $0
This is a lovely insert from She’s No LadyÂ Â that I had never seen before which was included in a lot with another insert from a film calledÂ Sailing AlongÂ starring Jesse Matthews. The $300 opening bid was a non-starter for me…and everyone else.
So there you have it! I wonderful assortment of Ann Dvorak memorabilia that I was not able to add to my collection. Fingers crossed that the people who purchased these large lots are not Dvorak fans, and I’ll get a second shot at these.